Call now: (512) 910-3825Open 8a-9p Mon-Sat · Licensed by Texas Parks & Wildlife

Bat Droppings vs. Rat Droppings: Is It Bats or Roof Rats in Your Houston Attic?

Houston attics get two common night-time tenants that leave dark droppings: bats and roof rats. They need completely different fixes, so it pays to know which one you have before you call anyone. Here is how to tell them apart with a flashlight, a paper towel and a few minutes outside at sunset.

Why Houston homeowners mix them up

Both animals are active at night, both get into attics through small gaps at the roofline, and both leave small, dark droppings. Houston has plenty of each. Texas Tech's Mammals of Texas says free-tailed bats use buildings in every Texas town (Mammals of Texas: Brazilian free-tailed bat), and Texas A&M AgriLife says the roof rat seldom burrows and normally nests in double walls and attics; if the nest is high, it is usually a roof rat's (AgriLife: Managing Rats and Mice). Mature live oaks, fruit trees and fences that touch rooflines give roof rats easy routes onto Houston houses.

The crumble test

This is the quickest way to tell. Put on disposable gloves and a mask, pick up a dropping with a paper towel, and press it. Bat droppings are made of insect parts, so they crumble into a dry, powdery dust, often with tiny shiny flecks of insect wings. Rodent droppings are firm and hard and don't crumble. FWC's guide to bats in buildings uses the same test: bat droppings crumble into powdery dust when crushed, mouse droppings don't, and you may see bits of metallic insect wings in bat scat (FWC: Bats in buildings).

Don't sniff or break droppings with bare hands, and don't do this in a dusty, enclosed attic without a respirator. See the cleanup section below.

Size, shape and where they land

  • Roof rat: about 1/2 inch long with pointed ends (ICWDM: roof rats). Scattered along the routes rats travel, on top of rafters, ductwork, insulation and the top plate of walls, and in kitchen cabinets if they reach the house.
  • House mouse: about 1/4 inch on average (ICWDM: house mice), scattered along runways and near food.
  • Bat: roughly rice-grain sized, dark brown to black, often irregular. The big tell is where they collect. Bats drop guano where they roost and below the gap they fly out of, so it builds into piles. Look on a windowsill, patio, deck, AC unit, or the ground under one spot on the roofline, and in the attic under the ridge, a gable or the top of a wall.

One dropping isn't enough to judge. Look at a handful, and pay attention to the pattern: a pile under one spot points to bats, a trail scattered along beams points to rodents.

Other signs that separate bats from rats

  • Gnawing. Rats gnaw wiring, wood, plastic pipe and stored boxes. AgriLife notes that bats won't gnaw their way through wood or building materials. Chewed wires or gnawed holes mean rodents.
  • Stains. Bats leave brown-black, oily rub marks at the edge of the gap they use (AgriLife). Rats leave dark greasy smears along the beams, pipes and wires they run.
  • Timing of the noise. Bat colonies make squeaking and rustling around dusk, when they get ready to leave, and again before dawn when they return. Rats scurry and scratch on and off all night.
  • Smell. A strong musky odor, noticeable in a closet or upstairs room, is typical of free-tailed bats. Rodents give off a sharper urine smell.
  • Nests and food. Shredded insulation, nesting material, pecan shells or chewed fruit mean rats. Bats don't build nests or bring food in.

The dusk watch: the most reliable test

Pick a warm evening, stand where you can see the roofline, and watch from about 15 minutes before sunset until dark. Bats leave the roost shortly after sunset. If you see bats dropping out of a gap in the soffit, fascia, gable vent or a roof return, one after another, you have a colony and you've also found the exits. Note every spot. That information makes the inspection faster.

No bats after a couple of warm evenings, but noise continues at night? Rodents become the more likely answer. Our guide to what's scratching in the attic covers squirrels, raccoons and other suspects.

Cleaning up droppings safely

Neither kind of dropping should be swept or vacuumed dry. Bat guano can grow the fungus that causes histoplasmosis, and NIOSH recommends respiratory protection and wetting material down to keep dust out of the air when disturbing accumulations (CDC/NIOSH: Histoplasmosis, protecting workers at risk). Rodent droppings and urine carry their own diseases. For a few droppings on a windowsill or patio:

  • Wear disposable gloves and a well-fitted N95 or better respirator.
  • Lightly mist the droppings with water or disinfectant so they don't raise dust.
  • Wipe up with paper towels, bag them, and wash your hands.

Piles in the attic or droppings worked into blown insulation are a job for a crew with proper gear. Our guide to bat guano and histoplasmosis in Texas explains what professional cleanup involves.

If it's bats

Bats can't be trapped or poisoned out of a house. The fix is exclusion: one-way devices over the active exits so the colony leaves to feed and can't get back in, then permanent sealing of every gap 3/8 inch or larger and cleanup of the guano. TPWD discourages exclusion from May 1 to August 15, when pups can't fly (TPWD Outdoor Annual), so a colony found in summer is planned for late August. Our Houston bat removal service handles the whole process, and our guide to bat removal costs in Houston explains what drives the price.

If it's rats

Roof rats need a different approach: trimming branches away from the roof, sealing gaps, and trapping, and a licensed pest control company is the right call. The sealing work overlaps with bat-proofing, so if you find both, tell whoever inspects the house.

Not sure what you're looking at? Call (512) 910-3825. Describe the droppings, where they are, and what you hear and when, and we'll tell you whether it sounds like bats.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell bat droppings from rat droppings?

Crush one with a gloved hand and a paper towel. Bat droppings crumble into powder, often with shiny insect wing bits. Rat droppings stay hard. Bat guano also piles up under one roost or exit, while rat droppings are scattered along travel routes.

What do roof rat droppings look like?

About 1/2 inch long with pointed ends, according to the Internet Center for Wildlife Damage Management. In attics they turn up along rafters, ductwork and the tops of walls.

Is it bats or rats in my Houston attic?

Watch the roofline at sunset on a warm evening. Bats leave shortly after sunset, one after another, from the same gaps. Squeaking at dusk and dawn suggests bats; scurrying all night, chewed wires and nesting material suggest rats.

Do bats chew through wires like rats?

No. Texas A&M AgriLife notes that bats do not gnaw through wood or building materials. Gnawed wires, pipes or boxes point to rodents.

Is it safe to clean up bat droppings myself?

A few droppings outside can be misted, wiped up with gloves and a respirator, and bagged. Do not sweep or vacuum dry guano. Large piles or guano in attic insulation should be handled by a crew with protective equipment because of histoplasmosis risk.

See our Houston bat removal service

Pretty sure it is bats? Let's confirm it.

Call for a phone consultation. Tell us what you are finding and where, and we will tell you what to look for and what the inspection covers.